VA Loan Network logo
  • Home
  • Apply Now
  • VA Loans
    • Programs
    • Today’s Rate
    • VA Guide
    • Refinance
    • Requirements
    • Benefits
    • State Guides
    • Calculator
  • Resources
    • Bases
    • Pay Center
    • BAH Rates
  • Learn
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Contact Us

The #1 Trusted Source for Veterans and Service Members

va loan network logo

SAME DAY APPROVAL

No Money Down, Low Interest Rates, No Mortgage Insurance

Check Your Eligibility

first lead form

"*" indicates required fields

Are you looking to purchase or refinance?
What is your goal?
Are you or your spouse retired or active military?
Active Military or Retired?
Are you receiving military retirement or VA Disability pay
Have you received PCS orders?
Where are you in the buying process?
Are you working with a real estate agent?
$350k - $400k
$0
$2m +
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Is this the first use of your VA entitlement?
What is your credit score?
Do you currently have a home to sell?
Do you currently have a VA loan on your property?*
$350k-$400k
$0
$2m +
$200k - $250k
$0
$2m +
$100k -$120k
What is the rate on your loan ?

Enter your contact details

Name*

By providing your name, email, and phone number, you consent to receive calls and texts from our VA loan specialists and lenders regarding your application. Message and data rates may apply. Your information will be used solely for this purpose. You can opt out at any time.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

White House Reverses Trump’s Veterans Day Renaming Proposal

by Ally Abernathy | May 6, 2025 | News

White House Reverses Trump’s Veterans Day Renaming Proposal

Veterans Day has its origins in Armistice Day, celebrated in 1918 at the end of World War I. It was eventually developed into a day of thanksgiving and remembrance for all U.S. military members.

On May 2nd, former President Donald Trump created a furor by suggesting that Veterans Day be renamed “Victory Day for World War I,” prompting concern among veterans’ groups over leaving out those who fought in subsequent wars.

Public protest and constitutional challenges forced the White House to promptly retract the plan and proceed instead to issue a commemorative proclamation. The article discusses the historical, political, and cultural implications of the proposal.

Check VA Loan Rates and Get Pre-Approved

AI Logo Your Article Summary
Paragraph Bullet Points

In this Article

  • Overview: The Controversial Proposal
  • A Brief History of Veterans Day
  • Key Milestones
  • Why Did Trump Propose Renaming Veterans Day?
  • Arguments For and Against the Renaming Proposal
  • Legislative Process for Renaming Federal Holidays
  • Public Opinion and Backlash
  • Personal Story: Vietnam Veteran’s Perspective
  • The White House Reversal: Why It Happened
  • Impact on Veterans and Evolving National Values
  • Potential Consequences and Future Outlook
  • Personal Reflections and Broader Debate
  • FAQs: Veterans Day Renaming Controversy
  • How to Support Veterans Beyond Veterans Day

Overview: The Controversial Proposal

On May 2, 2025, President Donald Trump announced a bold plan to rename Veterans Day—observed annually on November 11—to “Victory Day for World War I,” while designating May 8 as “Victory Day for World War II.” Shared via Truth Social, the proposal aimed to highlight what Trump described as America’s historical military brilliance and restore “American greatness,” echoing previous attempts such as Trump’s push to revert Mount Denali to Mount McKinley.

However, this move quickly raised alarms among veterans’ groups and political analysts who argued that it undermined the inclusive nature of Veterans Day, which honors all individuals who have served, not just those from the World Wars. By May 3, the White House had reversed course, confirming that the holiday would maintain its current name and promising an additional presidential proclamation to celebrate the victories of World War I and World War II instead.


A Brief History of Veterans Day

Key Milestones

  • 1918 (November 11): Armistice signed, ending major combat in World War I.
  • 1938: Congress establishes Armistice Day as a federal holiday.
  • 1954: Renamed Veterans Day to honor all American veterans after World War II and the Korean War.
  • 1971–1975: Briefly moved to the fourth Monday in October under the Uniform Monday Holiday Act, but reverted to November 11 in 1975.
  • 2025: Proposed “Victory Day for World War I” (reversed).

Originally known as Armistice Day, the holiday was instituted in 1938 to commemorate the formal end of fighting in World War I on November 11, 1918. In 1954, in response to veterans’ advocacy, Congress renamed it Veterans Day to recognize the growing number of Americans who served in World War II and the Korean War. Ever since, November 11 has been a day to honor all U.S. military veterans regardless of era or conflict.


Why Did Trump Propose Renaming Veterans Day?

  • Motivation and Rhetoric: According to Trump’s Truth Social post, America “doesn’t celebrate its victories enough,” referencing Allied celebrations for May 8 (Victory in Europe Day). Trump argued the United States should follow suit, marking a specific day for each major victory—World War I on November 11 and World War II on May 8. His stance aligned with his broader platform of restoring “American greatness,” similar to his effort to rename Mount Denali back to Mount McKinley.
  • Overlooked Realities: Critics immediately pointed out that Veterans Day was explicitly designed to include all veterans. By focusing solely on World Wars, the plan would exclude veterans from Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, and countless other conflicts. According to data from the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, of the 15.8 million living veterans, only around 66,000 World War II veterans remain. The proposal thus risked marginalizing over 99% of the veteran population.

Arguments For and Against the Renaming Proposal

  • For: Heightened National Pride. Proponents said emphasizing “Victory Days” would highlight American military prowess and unify citizens around historical triumphs.
  • Against: Exclusion of Modern Veterans. Over 99% of living veterans served post-World War II, making the proposed name change feel alienating and dismissive.
  • For: Alignment with Allies. Trump pointed to nations like France and the UK, which mark Victory in Europe Day on May 8.
  • Against: Legal Complexity. Renaming a federal holiday requires an act of Congress (as stipulated in Title 5 of the U.S. Code), not just a presidential decree.
  • Against: Historical Oversight. Trump’s emphasis on May 8 ignored the importance of V-J Day in August 1945, when the Pacific Theater concluded.

Legislative Process for Renaming Federal Holidays

Many are unaware that the U.S. President alone cannot legally rename a federal holiday. This authority belongs to Congress, as established by laws governing national observances (primarily found in Title 5 and Title 36 of the U.S. Code). Previous alterations to Veterans Day have undergone congressional debate and approval. In this instance, Trump’s White House conceded that pushing the proposal through Congress was not on their immediate agenda.


Public Opinion and Backlash

Veterans’ Organizations: Key groups, including the Disabled American Veterans (DAV), which represents over one million members, quickly denounced the renaming. The DAV issued a concise statement: “No,” criticizing what they viewed as a shift from “sacrifice to conquest.”

Social Media Reaction: Posts on X (formerly Twitter) and other platforms displayed frustration and ridicule. Some lamented Trump’s alleged disregard for the millions of veterans who served in more recent conflicts. Public opinion polls, where available, indicated that a majority of Americans favored retaining the name Veterans Day, although exact data is limited.

Personal Story: Vietnam Veteran’s Perspective

“I served in Vietnam from 1968 to 1969,” says John M., a 75-year-old retired Army medic. “Veterans Day isn’t about whether we won or lost; it’s about honoring everyone who stood up to serve our country. Changing the holiday’s name felt like erasing my service and the service of so many others.”


The White House Reversal: Why It Happened

Within a day of the announcement, Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt clarified the administration’s stance: “We are not renaming Veterans Day.” Instead, President Trump planned to issue a proclamation celebrating the victories in the World Wars. Several factors drove this rapid backtrack:

  1. Veterans’ Advocacy: Unified opposition from groups like the DAV and The American Legion put significant pressure on the administration.
  2. Public Relations Fallout: Critics labeled the move as “tone-deaf,” especially given past controversies around Trump’s own service record and statements about war heroes.
  3. Legal Considerations: A presidential proclamation, while symbolic, avoids the legislative hurdles of renaming a federal holiday.

Impact on Veterans and Evolving National Values

The rapid proposal and reversal highlighted broader questions about how America commemorates its veterans and wars. Some see the controversy as an example of the country’s struggle to balance celebrating victory with recognizing sacrifice. Others view it as a testament to veterans’ continuing influence in shaping public policy.

For many veterans, the debate underscored the importance of inclusion. In a country with 15.8 million living veterans spanning World War II, the Korean War, Vietnam, the Gulf War, and beyond, any policy change that appears to favor one group of veterans over another can incite intense backlash.

Table 1: U.S. Veteran Demographics (2023–2025)
ConflictEstimated Living VeteransNotes
World War II~66,000 (2025)Rapidly declining due to age
Korean War~500,000 (2023)Aging population
Vietnam War~6 million (2023)Largest group of living veterans
Gulf War / Iraq / Afghanistan~7 million (2023)Includes multiple operations
Total15.8 million (2023)Per U.S. Census Bureau

Potential Consequences and Future Outlook

While the November 11 holiday will remain Veterans Day for 2025 and beyond—unless Congress legislates otherwise—this episode may have a lasting impact on how future administrations and policymakers approach federal holiday revisions. It also emphasizes how vital it is to consider the perspectives of all veterans and the public before attempting to alter deeply ingrained national traditions.

Additionally, the White House’s reliance on a separate commemorative proclamation could become a model for addressing historical milestones without diminishing existing observances. However, with a nation still divided on political lines, any effort to reshape national holidays will likely spark intense debate about priorities, values, and the meaning of military service.


Personal Reflections and Broader Debate

For historians, the controversy underscores how rapidly social and political sentiments can clash over memorials and holidays. For veterans like Ava R., a Gulf War veteran from Texas, “It’s about recognition for all who served, no matter the era or the outcome of the conflict.” This notion resonates with the original intention of Veterans Day: an inclusive day of gratitude and reflection.

The Bottom Line

The short-lived attempt to rename Veterans Day is a reminder of the holiday’s universal origins and the powerful feelings it evokes in veterans, historians, and the public.

While President Trump wanted to accord more prominence to America’s World War victories, the ensuing controversy helped to highlight the richness of meaning that November 11 holds for all who have served.

Lastly, the White House pulled back the plan, preserving Veterans Day as an overall celebration of sacrifice and service. In the future, any discussion over the renaming of national observances will be likely to require scrupulous legislative cooperation and, above all else, deference to veterans’ diverse experiences.


FAQs: Veterans Day Renaming Controversy

Why did Trump want to rename Veterans Day?

Trump aimed to celebrate U.S. victories in World War I and II, arguing the nation doesn’t highlight its military triumphs enough. He proposed calling November 11 “Victory Day for World War I” and designating May 8 for World War II.

Why was the proposal reversed?

Intense backlash from veterans’ groups and legal realities—renaming a federal holiday requires congressional action—led the White House to revert to retaining Veterans Day’s name and issuing a separate proclamation for World War victories.

How are federal holidays renamed?

Only Congress can rename or establish federal holidays. The president may issue proclamations or executive orders, but these do not override legislative requirements.

What makes Veterans Day significant?

Since 1954, Veterans Day has recognized all who have served in the U.S. military, honoring sacrifices and diverse experiences across multiple eras.

Are there other precedents for renaming federal holidays?

Yes. For instance, Washington’s Birthday is commonly referred to as Presidents’ Day by many states, but any official renaming still requires an act of Congress.

Did Trump try to rename Mount Denali?

Yes. After President Obama renamed Mount McKinley to Denali in 2015, Trump voiced support for reverting it back to Mount McKinley, citing historical tradition.

How does the public generally feel about renaming Veterans Day?

Although detailed polls are limited, informal surveys and social media reactions suggest most Americans prefer honoring all veterans under the current holiday name.

Will Veterans Day change in the future?

For the immediate future, Veterans Day remains unchanged. Future adjustments would require legislative action and are unlikely without broad support from veterans’ organizations and the public.


How to Support Veterans Beyond Veterans Day

  • Donate: Consider supporting reputable organizations like the Disabled American Veterans (DAV) or the Wounded Warrior Project.
  • Advocate: Stay informed about VA funding and legislation affecting veteran benefits.
  • Volunteer: Participate in local veteran events, hospital visits, or mentorship programs.
  • Hire Veterans: If you’re a business owner, offer veteran hiring initiatives or special discounts.
  • Listen: Engage respectfully with veterans, seeking to understand their diverse experiences and needs.

Related Posts

donald trumpHow a Trump Presidency Would Affect the Housing Market donald trumpHow a Trump Win Could Impact Housing Policy in 2025 donald trumpTrump’s Push for Deregulation: A Boost for the Housing Market? donald trumpTrump Seen as Better for Stocks, Harris for Housing donald trumpWhat Happens to Housing Market if Trump Wins? donald trumpHow a Trump Presidency Will Affect Veteran Homebuyers

Latest Articles

  • VA Loan Inspection Requirements: The Ultimate 2025 Guide
    VA Loan Inspection Requirements: The Ultimate 2025 Guide
  • Dependency and Indemnity Compensation (DIC): Guide for Survivors
    Dependency and Indemnity Compensation (DIC): Guide for Survivors
  • Property Tax Exemptions for Surviving Veteran Spouses
    Property Tax Exemptions for Surviving Spouses of 100% Disabled Veterans
  • VA Loans on Memorial Day: Honoring Veterans’ Service
    VA Loans on Memorial Day: Honoring Veterans’ Service
  • 2025 Veterans can now pay buyer-broker fees on VA loans
    2025 Veterans can now pay buyer-broker fees on VA loans
  • 2025 VA Disability Payment Schedule
    2025 VA Disability Payment Schedule Released
  • Top Neighborhoods Near Lackland AFB for Military Families
    Top Neighborhoods Near Lackland AFB for Military Families
  • 2025 Veterans Pension Rates
    2025 Veterans Pension Rates
  • PTSD VA Ratings: Everything Veterans Need to Know
    How to Get a 100% PTSD VA Rating
  • va loans austin guide
    Best Places for Veterans to Live in Austin, Texas
  • best cities for veterans san antonio
    Top San Antonio Cities for Veterans
  • best neighborhoods in schertz, tx for Veterans
    Best Neighborhoods in Schertz, TX for Veterans
  • Proposed Changes to VA Disability Benefits in 2025
    Proposed Changes to VA Disability Benefits in 2025
  • VA Benefits Guide 2025 Released
    VA Benefits Guide 2025 Released: Everything You Need to Know

Our Latest Article

VA Loan Inspection Requirements: The Ultimate 2025 Guide

VA Loan Inspection Requirements: The Ultimate 2025 Guide

VA Loans

  • VA Loan Guide
  • VA Benefits
  • Credit Requirements
  • Loan Requirements
  • First-time Homebuyers
  • VA Loan Process
  • VA Certificate of Eligibility

About Us

    • Apply Now
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Legal Disclosures

 

Follow Us

  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow

Our Blog

  • Learn
  • VA Loans
  • Mortgage
  • Real Estate
  • Trends
  • Veteran Life
  • News
  • Credit

Copyright © 2025  VA Loan Network

3128 Napier Park, Suite 105 San Antonio, TX 78231 Phone: (800) 230-7201 Email: contact@valoannetwork.com

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Tumblr
  • Like